Hey all, I just got around to checking back on this thread, many more responses than I expected which is great. I appreciate all the information.
I am pretty close to making a decision, still a little on the fence since I am hoping for one controller for all things rather than 4 for one thing and 4 for another. I plan to order four of something today or tomorrow most likely. I personally prefer the Playstation style controller layout the most with both analog thumb sticks on the bottom, rather than the Xbox layout with the left analog on top and dpad on bottom. But that isn't all that important I guess, I am sure I would manage.
That Hori Fighting Commander looks awesome. I guess my ideal setup would probably be four of those for fighting games and retro console stuff, and then 4 PS4 controllers. I agree about the poor dpad and other issues with the XBox 360 wireless controllers, I started this thread because I have two of those controllers that are pretty out of whack and feel like I wasted my money on them.
I bought two 2600 Dapter-II usb interfaces for my Epyx 500xj joysticks to use with all those 1 button games for the Atari 2600 and C64 and other systems. My gaming history as a kid started with the Atari 2600, then to C64 and Amiga 500, and loved using the 500xj and slick stik and joysticks like those. I still cannot play games like H.E.R.O. or Montezuma's Revenge and countless others all that well on a dpad. I totally prefer the 500xj for those, I can get through the first 12 or so levels of H.E.R.O. without a single death on a 500xj and die repeatedly on a dpad, not sure why. I guess it's maybe how terrible the Xbox 360 wireless dpad is, or just me.
Ah man I really do not want to spend like $300 or more dollars on controllers today.
Is there a wired version of a Playstation controller that works well and is cheaper? I can't seem to find one. I am seeing tons of knockoffs of course but the reviews are pretty sketchy.