Belmont Posted September 22, 2019 Posted September 22, 2019 (edited) I'm diligently tracking changes to metadata for some platforms as I'm curating my own collections. Sometimes (rarely, but sometimes), i will notice games being deleted from the Game Database for no good reasons (to the extent of my own research). I'm wondering what's the thing to do in those cases? Re-add the game again (which will cause the game to have a new ID)? Contact someone? I've noticed in the past that some games I had submitted for deletions were "accepted" and then eventually came back. The process here seems to be a bit obscure. Thoughts? Ex: I had submitted the NES game "Ace Harding: Lost in Las Vegas" for deletion, which is a non-existant game (as far as I could tell, there isn't even a proto of it on carts or otherwise). It was accepted, and then it came back (whatever), so bringing a game back from the dead is possible. Ex: The perfectly valid game NES game "Brush Roller" was recently deleted, and I think we need it back. I realize these are the pitfalls of crowdsourcing -- I'm just looking for guidance on how to deal with those situations. Cheers! Edited September 22, 2019 by Belmont Quote
Jakatsu Posted September 23, 2019 Posted September 23, 2019 On 9/22/2019 at 7:08 PM, Belmont said: I'm diligently tracking changes to metadata for some platforms as I'm curating my own collections. Sometimes (rarely, but sometimes), i will notice games being deleted from the Game Database for no good reasons (to the extent of my own research). I'm wondering what's the thing to do in those cases? Re-add the game again (which will cause the game to have a new ID)? Contact someone? I've noticed in the past that some games I had submitted for deletions were "accepted" and then eventually came back. The process here seems to be a bit obscure. Thoughts? Expand If a perfectly valid entry has been deleted for some reason, then re-adding it back in is the way to go. Sometimes duplicate entries get deleted as they should, but not everyone understands the fact that sometimes two differently named entries are one and the same game. For example... On 9/22/2019 at 7:08 PM, Belmont said: Ex: The perfectly valid game NES game "Brush Roller" was recently deleted, and I think we need it back. Expand I submitted this for deletion. This game was released in Asia as Brush Roller and in Europe (more specifically Spain) as Booky Man (as per box title). Now, the reason for deleting Brush Roller was because the game was released outside Asia, the title of European release takes priority over Asian one. Basically, if a game has been released in North America, the name of that release takes priority over every other region. After that, Europe and after that Asia/Japan and rest of the world. So NA-> EU -> JP/Asia etc. This is one of the reasons why GamesDB has Alternate Name field, so that we can easily group different regional releases of the same game in one entry, thus avoiding duplicates. On 9/22/2019 at 7:08 PM, Belmont said: Ex: I had submitted the NES game "Ace Harding: Lost in Las Vegas" for deletion, which is a non-existant game (as far as I could tell, there isn't even a proto of it on carts or otherwise). It was accepted, and then it came back (whatever), so bringing a game back from the dead is possible. Expand You certainly did the right thing by submitting that entry for deletion, but I guess someone was adamant to adding it back in. In this case the responsibility falls to us, the moderators of the database, to research if the entry to be added is actually valid or not. Quote
Belmont Posted September 23, 2019 Author Posted September 23, 2019 Wow. My bad about Brush Roller -- i guess I'm putting too much trust in the no-intro P/C database Sounds good then! Thanks for the feedback 1 Quote
Jakatsu Posted September 23, 2019 Posted September 23, 2019 On 9/23/2019 at 1:01 AM, Belmont said: Wow. My bad about Brush Roller -- i guess I'm putting too much trust in the no-intro P/C database Sounds good then! Thanks for the feedback Expand To be fair, those pirate/unlicensed releases are a bit of a nightmare to keep track of, so no worries. Quote
MJF Posted September 23, 2019 Posted September 23, 2019 I never accept games to be deleted if the person provides NO reason. If it says No reason given, it's an automatic rejection from me 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.